Friday, October 11, 2013

The Washington Post and CBS-DC local news use contrasting styles of imagery to convey the same story at different parts of the event's unfolding.

Capitol Beltway (CBS DC local news)

When looking at these two different articles and two different pictures, several differences jump out at me. The Washington Post’s picture gives off a feeling of serenity; somewhat of a calm before the storm. The article explains how this “Truckers Ride for the Constitution” rally is coming, and it’s not joke.  The picture looks like it was taken on a nice morning, a little bit after sunrise.  The lighting is bright and the camera is panned out enough to show at least 30 cars going up and down the beltway.  Basically, this picture consists of a normal, fall morning; people are commuting to work as they do every day, but most of all, the beltway is problem free with no trucker traffic.
Capitol Beltway (Washington Post)

In CBS DC’s photo, you get a view of the protest after it started.  The picture appears to be taken from inside of a car that is currently stuck in traffic. The beltway is full of trucks that are planning to fill up the capital beltway to protest the federal government shutdown.  In this picture, unlike the first one, the picture casts a much gloomier feel.  It was taken today, so it is raining outside, and the sky is dark.  The picture basically casts the epitome of gloominess. 

One thing that CBS’s picture does an extremely good job of is appealing to the average citizen who might be reading the article.  The caption says, “A trucker convoy traveling 10 mph blocks all lanes of traffic on the Capital Beltway.” It’s raining, there’s horrible traffic, and the traffic isn’t moving any time soon. Almost every person reading this article will be able to empathize with the situation, and that is exactly what CBS local news is aiming for.  They use a picture which casts a view that resembles one taken from an everyday person, and that generally appeals very well to the masses.

As far as the quality of the pictures goes, the Washington Posts's picture is superior to CBS local news' picture. It is a professionally taken photo specifically designed to be in the Washington Post article. The second one looks like it was taken by a civilian and sent in to CBS, or taken by a reporter from their own car (which it was, in fact. It was taken by John Domen of All-News 99.1 WNEW). Essentially, it wasn’t taken by a professional photographer or even with any special photography equipment; it looks like it was taken from a phone, which seems to give the reader a sense of what it would be like to be in that driver’s seat. 

The photograph from The Washington Post is also a great reference picture for someone who is reading the story from CBS.  It can be used as a baseline to see what the Beltway looks like on a normal day.  As far as we know, the Post’s picture could have been taken yesterday, last month, or last year; the only thing that we really need to know is that the Beltway looks like that on a normal day when people are commuting (except in the case of normal rush hour traffic).